You are here

Are oil price benchmarks rigged just like LIBOR?

Section: Daily Dispatches

Total Warns over 'Inaccurate' Benchmarks

By Javier Blas
Financial Times, London
Monday, October 8, 2012

One of the world's largest oil trading groups has warned of "inaccurate pricing" in the benchmarks for the energy market that underpin billions of dollars of trading each day in contracts such as Brent and West Texas Intermediate.

Total Oil Trading SA, the trading arm of Total of France, has told international regulators that "several times a year, estimates of market prices on key [energy] indices ... are out of line with our experience of the day."

The International Organisation of Securities Commissions, an umbrella group of financial regulators, last week backed away from its initial tough proposals for regulation of the benchmarks in the physical energy market.


Prophecy Platinum Intercepts Best Pt+Pd+Au Grades Yet
at Wellgreen Project in Yukon Territory: 5.36 g/t

Company Press Release
Tuesday, September 11, 2012

VANCOUVER, British Columbia -- Prophecy Platinum Corp. (TSX-V: NKL, OTC-QX: PNIKF, Frankfurt: P94P) announces more results of its 2012 drill program on the company's fully-owned Wellgreen platinum group metals, nickel, and copper project in southwestern Yukon Territory, Canada. Four surface holes and four underground holes all intercepted significant mineralized widths, ranging from 28.5 meters (WS12-201) and up to 459.5 metres (WS12-193). Highlights include WU12-540, which returned 8.9 metres of 5.36 grams per tonne platinum, palladium, and gold; 1.73 percent copper; and 1.01 percent nickel within 304.5 meters of 0.66 g/t platinum-palladium-gold, 0.20 percent copper, and 0.27 percent nickel.

The surface drill program started in June and has completed 16 holes (assays pending for 12 holes) with two rigs now on site. The surface program continues to progress at a steady pace.

Prophecy Chairman John Lee commented: “Wellgreen is a very large nickel, copper, and platinum group metals project with near-surface high-grade zones. High-grade intercepts will be incorporated into resource modeling and mine planning in the pre-feasibility study. We expect further positive drill results from Wellgreen shortly.”

Wellgreen features a low 2.59-to-1 strip ratio, is situated at an altitude of 1,300 meters, and is only 15 kilometers from the two-lane paved Alaska Highway. Those factors significantly minimize the project's indirect costs.

For the complete company statement with full tabulation of the drilling results, please visit:

However, in a letter to Iosco, Total Oil Trading SA said that the way the benchmarks were calculated sometimes did not assure "an accurate representation of the market and consequently deform the real price levels paid at every level of the price chain, including by the consumer."

The trader, which is based in Geneva, added that "inaccurate pricing" was not only affecting the price of private, bilateral over-the-counter derivatives, but that "end users are directly impacted by erroneous prices."

Oil executives said the discrepancies were in the order of cents per barrel, rather than dollars.

The unusually candid public comments by the trading arm of Total have broken the omertà of the energy physical trading industry, a close-knit community in London, Geneva, Singapore, and Houston where disputes are usually settled in private.

Scrutiny of pricing in the energy market comes after the discovery of widespread manipulation of Libor, the benchmark for borrowing in interbank lending

Total Oil Trading undertakes activities similar to the trading arms of BP and Royal Dutch Shell and independent traders including Vitol and Glencore.

The letter, dated August 24, was released late on Friday by Iosco as an annex to its report about the physical energy market and the price-reporting agencies that collect and publish benchmarks, which largely suggested retaining the current status quo. Other oil companies whose letters were released, including BP and Saudi Aramco, defended the current system.

Total on Monday said in a statement that while it was "satisfied with the majority of the work done" by the price reporting agencies, its objective was to "to support any initiative encouraging even more transparent methodologies." The company added: "The current methodology contains, in very few cases, a small part of subjective judgment. ... We believe that this part of judgment could be mitigated."

Iosco, which groups financial regulators including the UK Financial Services Authority and the US Commodity Futures Trade Commission, sought this year to regulate the market in which price-reporting agencies, including Platts, a unit of New York-based McGraw-Hill, gather data about bids, offers, and trades and using proprietary methodologies publishes prices in what are otherwise opaque markets.

* * *

Join GATA here:

New Orleans Investment Conference
Wednesday-Saturday, October 24-27, 2012
Hilton New Orleans Riverside Hotel
New Orleans, Louisiana

* * *

Support GATA by purchasing DVDs of our London conference in August 2011 or our Dawson City conference in August 2006:

Or by purchasing a colorful GATA T-shirt:

Or a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:

Help keep GATA going

GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:

To contribute to GATA, please visit:


GoldMoney adds Toronto vaulting option

In addition to its precious metals storage facilities in Hong Kong, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom, GoldMoney customers now can store their gold and silver in a high-security vault operated by Brink's in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.

GoldMoney also has recently partnered with Rhenus Freight Logistics to offer another gold storage option in Switzerland. The Rhenus vault is in the secured zone of Zurich Airport and offers customers superb security as well as the ability to inspect their gold.

Storage at the new vaults in Canada and Switzerland is available at GoldMoney's lowest fees. Customers can select their storage location when placing their buy order.

GoldMoney customers can take delivery of any number of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bars from any GoldMoney vault, as well as personally collect their bars stored in the Hong Kong, Switzerland, and U.K. vaults.

It's easy to open an account, add funds, and liquidate your investment. For more information, visit: