South Africa notices gold fix controversy; GATA consultant Speck cited


Banks Bear Brunt of Gold-Fix Blame

By Chantelle Benjamin
The Mail & Guardian, Johannesburg
Friday, March 7, 2014

Evidence emerging in the United Kingdom about the possible manipulation of the gold price for a decade could have major implications for South African investors and mining companies who might be able to sue for damages in terms of South African law.

The London gold fix benchmark, set by five banks twice a day, is used worldwide by mining companies, central banks, and jewellers to value gold. A similar process, involving three banks, is used to value silver.

This week a New York resident, Kevin Maher, lodged a case in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York seeking unspecified damages against Barclays, HSBC Holdings, Bank of Nova Scotia, Societe Generale SA, and Deutsche Bank, on the grounds that they worked together and manipulated the benchmark.

... Dispatch continues below ...


Safe and Private Allocated Bullion Storage In Singapore

Given the increasing risks in financial markets, it is more important than ever to own physical bullion coins and bars and to store them in the safest vaults in the world in the safest jurisdictions in the world. Gold advocates Jim Sinclair and Marc Faber have recommended Singapore.

Now, with GoldCore, you can own coins and bars in fully insured, segregated, and allocated accounts in Singapore with the ability to take delivery. Learn more by downloading GoldCore's Essential Guide To Storing Gold In Singapore:

And for more information call Daniel or Sharon at +44 203 0869200 in the United Kingdom or at +1 302 635 1160 in the United States. Or email them at

He has based his case on a draft study by a renowned researcher, Rosa Abrantes-Metz, that was published by Bloomberg last week and said "it as likely that co-operation between participants had been occurring."

Her work is supported by research by Dimitri Speck, a commodity analyst.

Abrantes-Metz, a professor at New York University's Stern School of Business, is credited with helping to expose the London interbank offered rate (Libor) scandal. Her 2008 paper uncovered the rigging of the rate, which led to Barclays and UBS being fined about $6-billion.

Stanlib's Kobus Nell said there had been rumours for many years about the possible manipulation of the gold price but this is the first time that a study has been conducted by someone of her calibre.

In terms of the Competition Act, criminal or civil action can be taken against any company found guilty of collusion or price fixing, provided the activity took place in South Africa. That means any buying or selling in South Africa based on the gold fix price and undertaken with or by one of the five banks is covered by the act.

ENS attorney Theuns Steyn, who specialises in the mining sector, said this could have "huge" implications. "If trade is here and the branches of the banks are here, it could be possible to prove jurisdiction," he said. "The difficult part would be proving and quantifying damages."

The fix is calculated twice a day via a phone conference at 10.30 a.m. and 3 p.m. London time. The banks declare how many bars of gold they want to buy or sell at the current spot price, based on orders from their clients and themselves. The price is increased or reduced until the buy and sell amounts are within 50 bars of each other, at which point the fix is set.

An issue for many is that the bank traders can communicate with their clients and each other during the process. Traders can tell clients about shifts in supply and demand and take fresh orders during their conference call and can buy or sell as the price changes, according to the website of London Gold Market Fixing. And the process is unregulated.

The Libor is seen as the most important benchmark for setting short-term interest rates and, since 2000, has been calculated in 10 currencies. It was revealed in 2012, after an investigation, that some banks were falsely inflating or deflating their rates in order to profit from trades.

The Libor is a central cog in global financial markets against which financial products worth about $450 trillion are pegged.

Allegations about the rigging of the gold price, like those about the Libor, have been circulating for some time, although some analysts believe rigging would not have a big influence on the market because of the wide varieties of gold trading, from spot trading to gold exchange-traded funds.

Abrantes-Metz said in an 2013 Bloomberg article that, like the Libor manipulation, the gold fix is "controlled by a handful of firms with a direct financial interest in where it is set and there is virtually no oversight -- it's based on information exchanged" among themselves.

Nell said: "Gold is not a small market and there are tonnes being bought and sold every day, but it is possible that, over time, manipulation by the banks would have an impact.

"Of course, the problem is, with all the other information emerging about the banks, it does raise the question, if they could get involved in currency rigging, was it possible that other collusion was going on that we do not know about?"

Abrantes-Metz and some traders noticed "trading surges" after the 3 p.m. meeting and began writing about it about two years ago.

Abrantes-Metz, when approached by the Mail & Guardian, said: "The structure of the benchmark is certainly conducive to collusion and manipulation and the empirical data are consistent with price artificiality."

Her research, conducted with Albert Metz, the managing director of Moody's Investor Service, found there were frequent spikes in the gold price from 2004 after the 3 p.m. The study has been looking at the market from 2001.

But the large price moves were overwhelmingly down. For example, in 2010, large moves during the fix were negative 92 percent of the time.

She said that in the end it would be up to the regulators to establish why these movements began in 2004 and why prices tended to be downward.

In January this year Deutsche Bank announced that it was pulling out of the process for setting gold and silver benchmarks because of a decision to scale back its commodities business. But it emerged this week that it might have hired a consultancy to review the bank's role in the gold fix benchmark.

There has been market speculation that Standard Bank would be a good candidate to replace Deutsche Bank, particularly since it is selling its United Kingdom-based markets division to the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China and China last year became the biggest consumer of gold.

In reply to questions posed by the M&G, Deutsche Bank said: "Deutsche Bank is withdrawing its participation in the gold and silver benchmark setting process following the significant scaling back of our commodities business. We remain fully committed to our precious metals business."

Researcher Rosa Abrantes-Metz says that when it comes to the gold fix, "one needn't look to far for a motive. The participating banks all stand to gain both from using the privileged knowledge they glean during the fixing process and from influencing the fixing itself," she told Bloomberg last year.

Research by commodity analyst Dimitri Speck found that gold prices tend to drop sharply in the London afternoon fixing, with a less pronounced drop in London morning fixes. It also drops during the trading session of the Commodity Exchange (Comex) in New York.

Research by economist Paul Craig Roberts and analyst Dave Kranzler found that, in times of financial crisis, the price of gold is manipulated by central banks to calm or manipulate markets.

They said that the U.S. Federal Reserve has a vested interest in influencing the gold price, actively keeping it low. "When gold hit $1 900 per ounce in 2011, the Federal Reserve realised that $2 000 an ounce would have a psychological impact that would spread into the dollar's exchange rate with other currencies, resulting in a run on the dollar as both foreign and domestic holders sold dollars to avoid the fall in value."

They said the Fed began using "bullion banks as its agents to sell naked gold shorts in the New York Commodity Exchange [Comex] future market".

"Short selling drives down the price, triggers stop-loss orders and margin calls, and scares participants out of gold trusts. The bullion banks purchase the deserted shares and present them to the trusts for redemption in bullion."

They said the bullion could then be sold in the London physical gold market.

But Ross Norman, CEO of bullion brokers Sharps Pixley, believes that the large moves in price at the time of the fixings is because large selling and buying orders collide, and that there is more activity at 3 p.m. because that is when the US market opens.

* * *

Join GATA here:

Mines and Money Hong Kong
Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre
Monday-Friday, March 24-28, 2014
Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China

Canadian Investor Conference 2014
Vancouver Convention Centre West
1055 Canada Place, Vancouver, British Columbia
Sunday and Monday, June 1 and 2, 2014

* * *

Support GATA by purchasing DVDs of our London conference in August 2011 or our Dawson City conference in August 2006:

Or by purchasing a colorful GATA T-shirt:

Or a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:

Help keep GATA going

GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:

To contribute to GATA, please visit:


Jim Sinclair plans seminars in Los Angeles and San Diego

Gold advocate Jim Sinclair's next market analysis seminars will be held in Los Angeles from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Saturday, March 8, and in San Diego from 2 to 6 p.m. the following day, Sunday, March 9. Details, including registration information, are posted at Sinclair's Internet site,, here: