You are here

Gillian Tett in the Financial Times: It would be foolish to deride or ignore GATA

Section: Daily Dispatches

Is There a Shadowy Plot Behind Gold?

The Idea of a Central Bank Manipulating World Markets
Packs an Increasingly Powerful Emotional Punch with Voters

By Gillian Tett
Financial Times, London
Friday, October 21, 2011

Out there in the world today, a cabal of Western central bankers is secretly determined to manipulate the world's markets. They are doing this not via interest rates but by rigging gold prices.

More specifically, they have kept bullion prices artificially low in recent decades to ensure that our so-called fiat currency system -- that is, money created by central banks -- continues to work. For if the public ever knew the "real" price of gold, we would finally understand that our currencies, such as the dollar, are a sham. ... Hence the need for that central bank plot.

Does this sound like the ranting of a Tea Party activist? A Hollywood screenplay? Or could there be a grain of truth in it? The question has been provoking hot debate among a small tribe of investors in America for many years, particularly those owning gold mining stocks. Right now it is also leaching into the more mainstream American political world.

... Dispatch continues below ...


Golden Phoenix Signs Definitive Agreement to Acquire and Reopen Santa Rosa Gold Mine in Panama

Company Press Release
Monday, September 19, 2011

SPARKS, Nevada -- Golden Phoenix Minerals Inc. (OTC Bulletin Board: GPXM) has signed a definitive agreement to acquire a 60 percent interest, with an option to buy an additional 20 percent interest, in the Santa Rosa gold mine in Panama, now owned by Silver Global S.A., a Panamanian corporation.

Santa Rosa produced more than 100,000 ounces of gold from 1996 to 1998 before being closed in part to low gold prices, which are now more than five times higher.

Golden Phoenix intends to acquire its initial 60 percent interest in Santa Rosa by acquiring 60 percent of the share capital of a recently created company under the name Golden Phoenix Panama S.A., formed to hold and operate the mine.

Tom Klein, CEO of Golden Phoenix says: "The agreement establishes a solid framework from which we can advance Mina Santa Rosa to production-ready status."

For Golden Phoenix's complete statement, please visit:

As Republican candidates jostle ahead of the 2012 election, the question of whether America's central bank has been debasing its currency -- and how that is (or is not) linked to the value of gold -- is cropping up with new force. Herman Cain, the former pizza executive who is now a popular Republican contender, hinted last month that he would like to return to a world where "a dollar is a dollar" and added that "yes, we do need a gold standard for that." More recently, Newt Gingrich has voiced the same idea. Ron Paul, an outside Republican contender, has been lambasting the Federal Reserve for years over its easy-money policies. He is now darkly warning of plots.

A group called American Principles in Action created a Gold Standard 2012 platform last year and is now fighting to make these issues an election issue next year. And on the extremes of the Republican Party -- and more libertarian circles of American life -- a flock of theories about gold are now circling around, and taking root in the fertile soil of the internet.

I attended a dinner last week where Chris Powell, the treasurer of the Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee (GATA), was talking. Powell, an investigative journalist based in Connecticut, co-established GATA with a former commodities trader two decades ago, and he is convinced that the American government has long been manipulating gold prices as a matter of national policy. "Gold is a currency that competes with government currencies and has a powerful influence on interest rates and the value of government bonds," Powell explains. "This ... is why central banks have tried to control -- usually suppress -- the price of gold."

This rigging continues even today, he adds. Never mind the fact that the gold price has soared by 22 per cent in a year: to GATA it remains far below the "proper" -- non-manipulated -- price. Thus, when the gold price tumbled last month, Powell blamed this on central banks, who "meant to knock down the gold price at a crucial moment." (Check out for the arguments in full.)

Unsurprisingly, central bankers vehemently reject this plot idea. Indeed, when I pressed some of them on it, they laughed. "I never heard anything about any plots during my time at the Fed. We barely talked about gold at all," splutters one former Fed vice chairman, who points out that the Fed does not actually own any gold itself. Or as a European banker says: "How could we have secret deals for years, but nothing ever leaked?"

For my money, though, I think there are at least two reasons why it would be foolish simply to deride or ignore GATA. Firstly, some of its points have at least a grain of truth. Even if you find it hard to believe that central bankers would be dastardly enough to create a plot -- or competent enough to do what GATA claims -- the fact is that global commodity markets are pretty murky, central banks are often opaque, and Western rhetoric about "free" markets is often hypocritical. Those issues merit far more debate, not just among journalists but central bankers too.

Secondly, even if Western elites hate these gold conspiracy theories -- in fact, especially if they do -- they need to recognise that they tap into a deep cultural vein. Right now many Western voters are profoundly frightened about the economy. They are also confused by its unpredictable and mysterious nature. Consequently, the idea of a central bank "plot" packs an increasingly powerful emotional appeal, and voters are hungry for explanations and scapegoats. In that sense, the work of GATA might be seen as an echo of the cargo cults that anthropologists study in the Pacific islands: something that offers pattern and meaning amid terrifying disorder.

Whatever the "truth" behind these plot tales, the one thing that is clear is that these accusations are unlikely to disappear soon. Not, at least, while the world's economy remains so unstable and terrifying for ordinary mortals. Or, possibly, until that gold price really soars.

* * *

Join GATA here:

New Orleans Investment Conference
Wednesday-Saturday, October 26-29, 2011
Hilton New Orelans Riverside Hotel

Support GATA by purchasing gold and silver commemorative coins:

Or by purchasing a colorful GATA T-shirt:

Or a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:

Or a video disc of GATA's 2005 Gold Rush 21 conference in the Yukon:

Help keep GATA going

GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:

To contribute to GATA, please visit:


For Continuous Wealth Creation, the Hera Research Newsletter

The life cycles of companies that produce natural resources allow investors to allocate assets among companies at different stages of development and to profit from transitions between stages.

Based on natural resource company life cycles, the Hera Research Newsletter maximizes profits through deep, fundamental analysis at each stage of development and by moving gains back to earlier-stage companies in a continuous wealth-creation process.

Hera Research covers a pipeline of high-quality natural resource companies at different stages of development. The companies span discovery and production of gold, silver, and platinum group metals, select base metals, oil and gas, green energy, agriculture, rare earth elements, uranium, and more.

Discover the unique value of the Hera Research Newsletter by visiting:

Or call Ron Hera at 360-339-8541x101.